Description
Hermes sues an LA designer, accusing him of selling “MetaBirkin” branded NFTs that rip off the name and look of the handbag. A Jury unanimously found Defendant liable for trademark infringement, trademark dilution, cybersquatting, and awarded Plaintiffs $133k in damages. However, the Defendant is allowed to have a museum display his trademark-infringing NFT with signage that explains the infringement, thus elevating consumer confusion.
Legal Significance
NFTs that mimic trademarks of other entities can be held liable for infringement. However, those NFTs may still be displayed if there are clear indications that the mimicked trademark is not affiliated with the mark holder.
Issues
Status
Appeal
Case No.
1:22-cv-00384
Date Filed
January 14, 2022
Plaintiff
HERMÈS INTERNATIONALHermès of Paris Inc.
Defendant
Mason Rothschild
Court
USDC Southern District of New York
Plaintiff Counsel
Baker & Hostetler LLP
Defendant Counsel
Harris St. Laurent & Wechsler LLPLex Lumina PLLC
Major Filings
Related Developments
Bowen v. Li (FoundryPro Scam)
Bowen v. Li (FoundryPro Scam)
Settled
Brown v. Dolce & Gabbana USA
Brown v. Dolce & Gabbana USA
Complaint Filed
CFTC v. 1Pool
CFTC v. 1Pool
Settled
CFTC v. Mek Global Ltd.
CFTC v. Mek Global Ltd.
Complaint Filed
CFTC v. Ooki DAO
CFTC v. Ooki DAO
Settled
CFTC/FTC v. Voyager
CFTC/FTC v. Voyager
Motion to Dismiss
Coin Center v. Dept. Treasury (re: Tornado Cash Enforcement)
Coin Center v. Dept. Treasury (re: Tornado Cash Enforcement)
Appeal
Diamond Fortress v. EverID
Diamond Fortress v. EverID
Settled
Dufoe v. DraftKings
Dufoe v. DraftKings
Motion to Dismiss
Friel v. Dapper Labs, Inc. (Dapper Labs Class Action)
Friel v. Dapper Labs, Inc. (Dapper Labs Class Action)
Settled
Harper v. O’Neal (Shaq Class Action)
Harper v. O’Neal (Shaq Class Action)
Motion to Dismiss
Hastings v. Nifty Gateway, LLC
Hastings v. Nifty Gateway, LLC
Complaint Filed
Hermés v. MetaBirkins NFT
Hermés v. MetaBirkins NFT
Appeal
Holland v. CryptoZoo
Holland v. CryptoZoo
Motion to Dismiss
In Re Celsius Network LLC
In Re Celsius Network LLC
Complaint Filed
In Re Ethereummax Investor Litigation (EthereumMax Class Action)
In Re Ethereummax Investor Litigation (EthereumMax Class Action)
Motion to Dismiss
Johnson v. Maker Ecosystem Growth Holdings (Maker Foundation Class Action)
Johnson v. Maker Ecosystem Growth Holdings (Maker Foundation Class Action)
Settled
Johnson v. Musk (,Elon Musk Class Action)
Johnson v. Musk (,Elon Musk Class Action)
Settled
Patterson v. TerraForm Labs Pte Ltd. (Terra [Luna] Class Action)
Patterson v. TerraForm Labs Pte Ltd. (Terra [Luna] Class Action)
Motion to Dismiss
Real v. Yuga Labs (Yuga Labs Class Action)
Real v. Yuga Labs (Yuga Labs Class Action)
Motion to Dismiss
Sarcuni vs. bZx DAO (Ooki DAO Class Action)
Sarcuni vs. bZx DAO (Ooki DAO Class Action)
Dismissed
SEC v. BarnBridge DAO
SEC v. BarnBridge DAO
Settled
SEC v. Geosyn Mining
SEC v. Geosyn Mining
Motion to Dismiss
SEC v. Impact Theory
SEC v. Impact Theory
Settled
SEC v. Lee (Bitcoin Beautee)
SEC v. Lee (Bitcoin Beautee)
Complaint Filed
SEC v. Quantstamp
SEC v. Quantstamp
Settled
SEC v. Ripple
SEC v. Ripple
Settled
SEC v. Stoner Cats 2
SEC v. Stoner Cats 2
Settled
SEC v. TerraForm (Luna)
SEC v. TerraForm (Luna)
Settled
Shin v. ICON
Shin v. ICON
Motion to Dismiss
Singh v. Illusory Systems (Nomad Bridge Hack Civil Case)
Singh v. Illusory Systems (Nomad Bridge Hack Civil Case)
Motion to Dismiss
Teed v. Chen
Teed v. Chen
Motion to Dismiss
Texas Blockchain Council v. Department of Energy
Texas Blockchain Council v. Department of Energy
Complaint Filed
Thomson vs. Persistance Technologies
Thomson vs. Persistance Technologies
Complaint Filed
USA v. Atcha
USA v. Atcha
Complaint Filed
USA v. Chastain (OpenSea Insider Trading)
USA v. Chastain (OpenSea Insider Trading)
Appeal
USA v. Harmon (2)
USA v. Harmon (2)
Complaint Filed
USA v. Michel
USA v. Michel
Settled
Yuga Labs v. Lehman (Yuga Labs Trademark Infringement)
Yuga Labs v. Lehman (Yuga Labs Trademark Infringement)
Settled
Yuga Labs v. Ripps (Yuga Labs Trademark Infringement)
Yuga Labs v. Ripps (Yuga Labs Trademark Infringement)
Settled